Tag: history

Hubayrah The Poet

Hubayrah was supposedly on the list to be killed for writing mocking poems on the Prophet. However, we have reported before that Prophet Mohammad never retaliated against anyone for his own sake. Hence, the story cannot be true. Islamic scholar Allama Shibli elucidates further on why the story is not true. PROCLAIMED CULPRITS Chroniclers name… Read More ›

Abdullah Ibn Zib’ari The Poet

The Claim critics is that Abdullah ibn Zib’ari was on the list to be killed for writing insulting poems about the Prophet. However, Islamic scholar Allama Shibli goes into detail refuting this false story attributed to the Prophet (p): PROCLAIMED CULPRITS Chroniclers name ten persons, who, notwithstanding the general amnesty granted to the Meccans, were declared… Read More ›

Huwayrith Ibn Nafidh (or Nuqayth – Naqidh)

Or Huwairith ibn Nukaidh ibn Bujar ibn Abd ibn Kusai Huwayrith ibn Nafidh was another killed by the order of Prophet Muhammad (p). It is reported in Ibn Hisham’s footnotes (804) that one of his crimes was that he abused the two daughters of Makkah when they were leaving Makkah. 804. Al-Abbas had put Fatima… Read More ›

Sarah The Poet – Seerah

It is claimed by critics that Mohammad (p) wanted Sarah to be killed because she verbally abused him. However, as we have documented before using authentic Hadith, these allegations hold no weight whatsoever. The Prophet’s wife Aisha in a number of Hadith attests that Mohammad (p) never took personal revenge for his own self. Narrated… Read More ›

Story Of Fartana The Poet

It is alleged by critics that when Prophet Muhammad (p) conquered Makkah, he ordered the killing of a slave girl because she was “reciting insulting poems” about Mohammad. He (p) in turn ordered that she be killed. Scholar, Shaykh Allama Shibli Numani goes into detail on this, showing that the story of Fartana being killed… Read More ›

Abdullah Ibn Sa‘ad Ibn Abi Sarh Apostasy Or Murder?

The Prophet (p) did not order Abdullah Ibn Sa‘ad Ibn Abi as-Sarḥ to be killed for apostating. Rather, the Hadith and other sources tell us that once he left Islam, he joined the Makkan pagans in war against the Prophet (p). Narrated Abdullah ibn Abbas: Abdullah ibn Abu Sarh used to write (the revelation) for… Read More ›

Hadith On The Nameless Spy

The nameless man was killed because of the evidence we have from sources. He was not innocent. The Makkans persecuted the Muslim community for many years and now a spy appeared trying to collect information so he can give back to the enemy and they used that information to attack the Muslims. Narrated Salama bin… Read More ›

Was Umm Qirfa Innocent?

The story of Umm Qirfa comes up frequently by critics to show how Mohammad and his companions were barbaric for killing a woman as claimed by them for merely being ‘a noble woman of high rank who did nothing wrong other than adhere to her traditional beliefs’. It is portrayed by critics that she was… Read More ›

Miqyas ibn Subabah Joined The Enemies

A person accidently killed Miqyas’s brother. The Prophet (p) gave Miqyas blood money to resolve his brother’s accidental death. Miqyas accepted the money but later murdered his brother’s killer. One must take note here, the person who killed Miqyas’s brother did so accidentally. In contrast, what Miqyas did was pure treachery, by killing someone unlawfully… Read More ›

Abu Rafi’ ibn Abi Al-Huqaiq The Warmonger

Kaleef K. Karim Abu Rafi’ ibn Abi Al-Huqaiq is another person who was killed in the lifetime of Prophet Muhammed (p). The reasons were that he incited others to go to war against the Muslims. He even supplied the enemies of the Muslims with ammunition, and other things needed to go to war against the… Read More ›

« Older Posts
Newer Posts »